In the news: a top official of the US Bishops Conference - a priest, Msgr. Jeffrey Burrill - has resigned after it became public through reporting that he frequents gay bars and uses the gay dating and sex app, Grinder.
It is almost laughable to watch the Catholic press telling us to "move along, nothing to see here".
Someone not Catholic might think ... oh no, a celibate priest, one high up in the political infrastructure, has been revealed to be gay and sexually active.
But those Catholics who are reporting on this are carefully *not* going there. Instead, they are (1) attacking the source of the reporting, (2) attacking what they see as a homophobic reaction to the news, or (3) saying that the "liberal" viwepoint should be to protect the priest's privacy and to shrug off the sex (
Peter Steinfels actually wants us to believe he is a liberal - ask him how he feels about a womsn's right to choose).
I, however, *am* a liberal, and I will tell you what a liberal would think about this news of Msgr. Jeffrey Burrill and his Grinder account.
(1) It doessn't matter who reported the news if the facts are accurate.
(2) It is not homophobic to note that a gay priest is lying to the faithful about being sexually active.
(3) This news is indeed a big deal, though church people like Steinfels say it's inconsequential. Why does it matter? Because ...
- The Catholic church and the pope are always and constantly telling not just Catholics but everyone how to live their lives, telling us what is good and what is bad, telling us that only they know what God really wants.
- The church and the pope have spent a lot of time telling us that sex outside of marrigae is bad for straight people, telling us that any sex is bad for gay people.
- The church tells us that the Catholic priesthhod is celibate, though reporting for decades has shown that about 50% of priests are sexually active with other adults (both straight and gay), and that many priests are pedophiles.
So why is a sexually active priest high up in leadership not an issue for Catholic pundits?
If it's ok for priests to have sex, and I think it should be, then officially do away with the "celibate" priesthood. If being LGBTQ is ok, and I think it is, then stop teaching that gay people are "intrinsically disordered",and stop lobbying against marriage for LGBTQ people.
Despite what Steinfels says, liberals actually care about facts, they care about honesty, they care about trust. Liberals are repelled by a churcch that so casually lies to us, that tells us to live one way while they live another, and that tells gay men that the only real family they can ever find is in the priesthood.
And this explains why there are very few liberals left in the Catholic church. Those who call themselves liberals are mostly Republican apologists for a religious/political institution that still benefits them, despite its hypocrisy and corruption.